I still remember the first night I dropped into Elden Ring Nightreign and hated it. Like a lot of FromSoftware fans, I had built up a wall of resistance to the idea of an Elden Ring spinoff designed almost entirely around multiplayer. I wanted the next proper Souls game. I wanted to get lost in a huge, mysterious world alone, not queue up with strangers and hope they knew what they were doing. And then I played a few runs without comms, and my worst fears came true: tagging is not a language, and random teammates are not always fluent in it.

The turning point was simple. I had two friends who were also deep into Elden Ring, and we started playing Nightreign together on voice chat. Suddenly, the game made sense. We could call out gear, plan our route, and decide whether to push for one more landmark or play it safe before the closing circle. Nightreign with comms is night and day compared to Nightreign with silence. That is the caveat I would give anyone in 2026: if you have one or two Elden Ring-loving friends, this game is a fantastic time. If you do not, you may still enjoy it, but you will be signing up for a very different and much more frustrating experience.
The comms problem is real
Nightreign is a roguelike built around team interplay. You drop into a map with random landmarks, gather runes to level up, and chase gear and passives that make your Nightfarer stronger. At the end of each night, a death circle closes in, and you fight a night boss. Survive two nights, and you face a Nightlord in a large-scale boss battle. If you wipe during a run, you can recover. If you all die to a night boss or the Nightlord, it is game over.
That structure practically begs for coordination. Without voice chat, you are limited to tagging, and tagging cannot explain why you are pinging a chest, whether you want to skip a fight, or why your teammate should absolutely not stand in that particular patch of glowing death. Predictably, this leads to endless frustrations and horror stories. I have seen enough of them to know I am not alone. The game does not have built-in comms, and for a multiplayer roguelike about sharing gear and surviving together, that is an important flaw.
| With comms | Without comms |
|---|---|
| Share gear and strategise in real time | Tagging only |
| Coordinate boss bursts and retreats | Silent panic |
| Laugh at wipes together | Rage at randoms |
| Learn passives as a group | Guess and hope |
How a run actually works
You play as Nightfarers, characters with specific skills and stats. My favourite is Raider, mostly because his ultimate ability is gloriously ridiculous. He summons a giant rock that characters and bosses can clip through, and it does not even protect you properly against ground-based threats while you are standing on it. Does that stop me from using it in the middle of a boss fight and enjoying the chaos? Of course not. That is part of the charm.
Nightreign is unbalanced in the way FromSoftware multiplayer games often are. It is not quite as hilariously broken as Elden Ring was at launch, but it still has moments that make you laugh out loud. Until recently, one of my teammate's builds in Deep of Night revolved around a very specific flail because its skill did obscene damage for seemingly no reason. A great deal is still not explained. Even now, I am learning new information about which passives can stack and how they work. For some players, that is a bug. For me, it is the whole point.

I love the way Elden Ring, Dark Souls, and Bloodborne obfuscate information and leave you to work things out. I love the jank and the imbalance, because they lead to total nonsense in the middle of a boss fight. Nightreign is a bad multiplayer game if you judge it by the standards of most other multiplayer games. But the flaws I am describing are not things I would ever want FromSoftware to change. They are part of the studio's design DNA.
A victory lap for Elden Ring sickos
In many ways, Nightreign acts as a victory lap for Elden Ring. A lot of it is reused content, bringing bosses, enemies, weapons, and assets from the base game and remixing them into a big bubbling pot of roguelike chaos. If you are someone like me, who has an almost categorical knowledge of Elden Ring, it is a really fun time. I guided the game at launch, and being able to actively apply that hard-won knowledge during each run feels great.
Whether we are talking skills, weapons, boss weaknesses, or spells, Nightreign rewards players who were really into Elden Ring and who love the role that knowledge has always played in FromSoftware games. Throw Dark Souls bosses into the mix, plus Nightlord invasions, random events, and the Shifting Earth, which changes the map entirely, and you have a game fans can sink their teeth into.
The 2026 state of play
Looking back now in 2026, Nightreign is in the best state it has been since launch. FromSoftware has done a genuinely good job supporting it and fleshing out content. After launch, we got the Everdark Sovereigns, superpowered versions of the Nightlord bosses with additional mechanics. Those fights are challenging, but they are also fun to work away at. Deep of Night was added as an endgame mode that gets progressively harder as you gain XP, and it offers new powerful passives and relics. One especially great modifier removes all map markers, so you navigate by knowledge and line of sight alone.
We also got The Forsaken Hollows DLC. It did not add the Shadow of the Erdtree weapons, spells, and skills everyone was craving, but it brought a new map, two extremely fun Nightlord bosses, and two Nightfarers who fill niches that were lacking. The Scholar especially helps make Nightreign's items actually worthwhile, levelling them up as he uses them.
With the DLC out and the game supported so well, I think it is likely FromSoftware will move on to new pastures next year. But if you are like me, hungry for the next Souls, Bloodborne, or whatever it may be, Nightreign is absolutely worth diving into now. If you have one or two Elden Ring-loving friends and you are looking for something to play this festive season, I would recommend it without hesitation. Just bring comms. The Nightlords are hard enough without having to guess what your teammate is thinking. 🎯💀
Comments